Constructing a Set of Indicators for Performance Assessment in Higher Education Establishments
The current phase of the socio-economic development in Ukraine is marked by the transformation in the national higher education system in order to harmonize it with international standards. These standards are based on the basically new competence-oriented paradigm of the higher education, making emphasis on the quality of higher professional education. An important component of the education quality is the performance of a higher education establishment (HEE), which significance is growing given the increasing competition among HEEs and stricter requirements to the transparence and information openness of their operation. This raises the relevance of the problem related with selection of indicators for assessment of HEE performance.
It is pointed out that methodical approaches to quality assessment of HEEs for official accreditation and ranking purposes, practiced in Ukraine now, include the indicators capable for only fragmented assessment of HEE results and focused on education processes. These approaches to performance assessment in HEEs cause a gap between the quality of HEE performance and the quality of education provided by them. It is found that variations between indicators of domestic and international rankings by which HEE performance is assessed occur because international rankings, in contrast to domestic ones, account only for HEE performance, including job placement of graduates or applications of R&D, whereas ways to achieve the performance are considered as a matter of HEE choice.
A theoretical and methodological approach to constructing a set of indicators of HEE performance is justified, which is based on the principle that a set of these indicators must provide as full as possible coverage of goals and operative tasks of HEEs, specified in the Law of Ukraine “Higher Education”. It is argued that the result of education process as a propriety operative task of HEE must be specific achievements of graduates, expected and measurable. A set of the indicators measuring results of education activities is proposed. A number of new indicators in addition to R&D spending are proposed for assessment of R&D in HEEs. Also, specific indicators are proposed for assessment of task completion: established international relations and performed international actions in the field of education; the increased education and cultural level of citizens.
It is concluded that assessment of HEE performance need to be made by multi-criteria set of components and be based on a system of estimates.
Pro vyschu osvitu. Zakon Ukrainy vid 01.07.2014 r. № 1556-VII, stanom na 01.09.2018 r. [On Higher Education: Law of Ukraine. 01.07.2014 № 1556-VII, as of 01.09.2018]. zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1556-18. Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1556-18 [in Ukrainian].
Sistemy menedzhmenta kachestva. Osnovnye polozheniia i slovar [Quality management system. Fundamentals and vocabulary]. (2005). HOST R ISO 9000-2005 from September 15th, 2005. Moscow: Gruppa kompanii “Intersertifika” [in Russian].
Svizhevska, S. A. (2014). Akredytatsiia yak imidzheva stratehiia pidvyshchennia yakosti vyshchoi osvity [Accreditation as a image strategy for improving the higher education quality]. Visnyk NTUU “KPI”. Filosofiia. Psykholohiia. Pedahohika – Visnyk of National Technical University of Ukraine "Kyiv Polytechnic Institute" Philosophy. Psychology. Pedagogics, 1 (40), 110–115 [in Ukrainian].
Pro zatverdzhennia Natsionalnoi ramky kvalifikatsii: Postanova Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 23.11.2011 r. № 1341, stanom na 01.09.2018 r. [On approval of the National qualifications framework: Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine of November 23, 2011, № 1341, as of September 1, 2018]. zakon.rada.gov.ua. Retrieved from https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/1341-2011- % D0% BF [in Ukrainian].
Pro zatverdzhennia Polozhennia pro akredytatsiiu vyshchykh navchalnykh zakladiv i spetsialnostei u vyshchykh navchalnykh zakladakh ta vyshchykh profesiinykh uchylyshchakh: Postanova Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 09.08.2001 r. № 978, stanom na 01.09.2018 r. [On Approval of the Regulation on Accreditation of Higher Educational Institutions and Specialties at Higher Educational Institutions and Higher Professional Schools: Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine of August 9, 2001, № 978, as of September 1, 2018]. zakon.rada.gov.ua. Retrieved from https: //zakon.rada.gov.ua / laws / show / 978-2001-% D0% BF [in Ukrainian].
Rozhnova, T. Ye. Kryterii ta pokaznyky otsiniuvannia rezultatyvnosti upravlinnia VNZ na zasadakh innovatsiinykh tekhnolohii [Criteria and indicators of evaluation of the effectiveness of management of higher educational institutions on the basis of innovative technologies]. eprints.zu.edu.ua. Retrieved from http://eprints.zu.edu.ua/10067/1/.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Krasovska, O. Yu. (2011). Marketynhovyi monitorynh yak instrument doslidzhennia svitovoho rynku vyshchoi osvity [Marketing monitoring as a tool of research of the world market of higher education]. Ekonomichnyj visnyk universytetu: zbirnyk naukovykh prats uchenykh ta aspirantiv – Collection of Scientific Articles “University Economic Bulletin”, Is. 16/1, 93–99 [in Ukrainian].
Riabova, Z. V. (2014). Marketynhove upravlinnia v osviti: tekhnolohichnyi aspekt [Marketing Management in Education: Technological Aspect]. Narodna osvita – Popular Education, 3(24). Retrieved from https://www.narodnaosvita.kiev.ua/?page_id=2612 [in Ukrainian].
Stankevych, I. V. (2018). Upravlinnia diialnistiu osvitnoi orhanizatsii na zasadakh bahatovymirnoho otsiniuvannia yakosti [Management of the activity of educational organization on the basis of multivariate quality assessment]. Extended abstract of Doctor’s thesis. Dnipro [in Ukrainian].
Valenkevych, L. P., & Finkilshtein, O. V. (2013). Analiz suchasnykh reitynhiv vyschykh navchalnykh zakladiv yak instrumentu otsinky yakosti vyshchoi osvity [Analysis of contemporary ratings of higher education institutions as a tool for assessing the quality of higher education]. Derzhavne rehuliuvannia protsesiv ekonomichnoho i sotsialnoho rozvytku – State regulation of processes of economic and social development, 3 (42), 36–42 [in Ukrainian].
Academic Ranking of World Universities: Methodology (n. d.). www.shanghairanking.com. Retrieved from http://www.shanghairanking.com/shanghairanking-subject-rankings/Methodology-for-ShanghaiRanking-Global-Ranking-of-Academic-Subjects-2018.html [in English].
CWUR World University Rankings 2018–2019. (n. d.). cwur.org. Retrieved from https://cwur.org/2018-19.php [in English].
QS World University Rankings (n. d.). www.topuniversities.com. Retrieved from https://www.topuniversities.com/qs-world-university-rankings [in English].
Round University Ranking. Clarivate Analytics. (n. d.). Retrieved from http://roundranking.com/ [in English].
Metodyka vyznachennia reitynhiv universytetiv Ukrainy TOP-200 Ukraina [Methodology for determining the ratings of Ukrainian universities TOP 200 Ukraine]. (n.d.). osvita.org.ua. Retrieved from www.osvita.org.ua/abitur/entrance/ratings/1.html [in Ukrainian].
Vyshcha osvita v Ukraini u 2017 r.: stat. zb. [Higher education in Ukraine in 2017: Statistical Yearbook]. Derzhavna sluzhba statystyky Ukrainy (2018). Retrieved from http://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/druk/publicat/kat_u/publosvita_u.htm [in Ukrainian].
Osnovni pokaznyky diialnosti vyshchykh navchalnykh zakladiv Ukrainy na pochatok 2016/2017 navchalnoho roku [The main indicators of the activity of higher educational institutions of Ukraine at the beginning of 2016/2017 academic year]. Derzhavna sluzhba statystyky Ukrainy (2018). Retrieved from http://www.ukrstat.gov.ua/druk/publicat/kat_u/publosvita_u.htm [in Ukrainian].
Voskresenskaia, N. M. (2004). Opyt razrabotki standartov obrazovaniia v zarubezhnyh stranah [Experience in developing educational standards in foreign countries]. ecsocman.hse.ru. Retrieved from http://ecsocman.hse.ru/data/031/1219/08voskresenskaya143-161.pdf [in Russian].
Akinfieva, N. V. (2013). Sravnitelnyi analiz kriteriev otsenki kachestva vysshego obrazovaniia [Comparative analysis of criteria for assessing the quality of higher education] Retrieved from https://www.sgu.ru/sites/default/files/textdocsfiles/2013/07/15/akinfieva_0.pdf [in Russian].
Shtymak, A. (2015). Tekhnolohiia vyznachennia rivnia kompetentnosti vypusknyka VNZ z vykorystanniam alhorytmiv nechitkoho lohichnoho vyvedennia [The technology of determining the level of competence of a graduate of an institution of higher education using algorithms of fuzzy logic output]. Visnyk Natsionalnoho universytetu “Lvivska politekhnika”. Seriia: Kompiuterni nauky ta informatsiini tekhnolohii: zbirnyk naukovykh prats – Bulletin of the National University “Lviv Polytechnic”. Series: Computer Science and Information Technologies: collected papers, 826, 109–122. Retrieved from https://dspace/uzhnu.edu.ua/jspui/bitstream/lib/9060/1/17-109-122.pdf [in Ukrainian].
Korduba, Yu. (2014). Do pytannia vzaiemodii VNZ iz rynkom pratsi v Ukraini ta modeli vzaiemodii yevropeiskykh universytetiv iz pratsedavtsiamy [To the issue of interaction of higher education institutions with the labor market in Ukraine and the models of interaction between European universities and employers]. Imperative of quality: learn to appreciate and evaluate higher education. T. Dobko, M. Holovianko, O. Kaikova, V. Terziian, T. Tikhonen (Ed.). Lviv: Kompaniia Manuskript [in Ukrainian].
Pasport profesii. [Passports of the profession]. (2013). sustainability.scm.com.ua. Retrieved from https://sustainability.scm.com.ua/uk/about_scm/sustainable_development/cases/case/91/1 [in Ukrainian].
Kompaniia SKM predstavyla rezultaty proektu “Pasport profesii” [SCM company presented results of the project “Passport profession”]. (2013). sustainability.scm.com.ua. Retrieved from https://sustainability.scm.com.ua/ru/media_centre/news/detail/1064/ [in Ukrainian].
Vasileva, E. Yu. (2010). Udovletvorennost rabotodatelei kachestvom podhotovki vypusknikov vuzov v vysokotekhnologicheskom sektore rynka truda [Satisfaction of employers by quality of accepted graduates of high schools in a hi-tech segment of the market of professional work]. Universitetskoe upravlenie: praktika i analiz – University Management: Practice and Analysis, 4, 28–36 [in Russian].
Tretiakova, T. V. (2009). Analiz podhodov k otsenke kachestva obrazovaniia za rubezhom [Analysis of approaches to the quality assessing of education abroad]. cyberleninka.ru. Retrieved from https://cyberleninka.ru/article/v/analiz-podhoodov-k-otsenke-kachestva-obrazovaniga-za-rubezhom [in Russian].
Abstract views: 6 PDF Downloads: 36